This month at the ReelChange Drive In, the watch word is Sherlock.
With the popularity of Fox’s “House” in the air
we thought we’d look at some other unusual revisions of Sir
Arthur Conan Doyle’s greatest creation.
We
start off the evening with the 1970 Billy Wilder curio The Private
Life of Sherlock Holmes. Wilder was beginning his elder statesman
years when he and I.A.L. Diamond took on this massive virtuoso work,
or at least that’s what it was supposed to have been. They wrote
the picture like a symphony, with an overture and various movements
in an episodic fashion. In many ways this format became its undoing.
UA had lost a ton of dough in the previous few years and got dodgy
about releasing a 3-hour-plus masterwork. The film’s road show
format just didn’t seem feasible at the time. The episodic nature
of the picture allowed the studio to “cleanly” cut more
than an hour out of the work, leaving us with what we have today.
Don’t
misunderstand, the picture is still a great one, but it is definitely
hobbled a bit. Wilder opens the picture nicely with an episode that
questions both Holmes’ stand on women as well as his relationship
with Dr. John Watson. Interestingly, these are the most common subjects
to come up in modern takes on the original consulting detective. Generally
the revisionists seem to believe that Watson has made Sherlock too
much of a “character” and he is forced to adhere to his
public image, and that although Holmes shows distain for the majority
of the human race our modern sensibilities panic when that distain
pertains to women too.
This freak-out about Holmes and women far too often discounts or
outright ignores Irene Adler or “That Woman.” The only
woman (and damn near the only person) to outsmart Holmes was of course
the only one to get near his three-sizes-too-small heart. This brings
us to the second half of this month’s double feature, Zero Effect.
As much as Private Life is the work of an old master, Zero Effect
is the work of a young, bright legacy. In his debut as a writer/director,
Jake Kasdan, son of Lawrence, lands an almost perfect film his first
time out. Zero Effect is a nicely aware, but not self-conscious update
of Holmes and Watson. In Kasdan’s version, Sherlock Holmes becomes
Daryl Zero, his homebodiness becomes agoraphobia, his detachment borders
on sociopathic, and his eccentricity becomes annoying. Zero is so
annoying that his Watson, Steve Arlo, is about to quit and refuses
to chronicle the detective’s adventures.
Kasdan
does what far too many modern quirky detective writers forget to do:
in Zero Effect he actually constructs a clever and intriguing mystery
along with fascinating characters. Zero Effect was praised by the
critics when it was released, but it was forgotten at the box office
and almost as ignored on home video. Here’s your chance to see
two talents working with similar material at opposite ends of their
respective careers.
Special late feature: The 7% Solution