Get out your measuring cup. To prevent a skin from forming, press plastic wrap directly onto the surface of the pudding. This warm version of the cult-classic treat is so creamy and the amazing butterscotch flavor is one you … In my other batches I used a lot more sweetened condensed milk and butterscotch topping. 3. It’s the perfect combination of hot chocolate and butterscotch! Even if you don't know what butterbeer is, you definitely need to give this recipe a try. Whisk the butter into the pudding along with the 2 teaspoons of vanilla extract. didn't quite follow the measurements (blame the sweet tooth!) My son added a candy cane to his to stir and the peppermint flavor was good too. Get our easy three-ingredient butterbeer recipe and details about this yummy drink. The flavors are a caramelly, creamy goodness. First, butterscotch. Place in a greased 8×8″ baking dish. Filed Under: Recipes Tagged: Autumn, Butterbeer, Butterscotch, Desserts, Easy Homemade Stovetop Pudding Recipe, Fall, Gluten-Free, Grain-Free, Halloween, Harry Potter, Harry Potter Inspired Recipes, October Treats, Pudding, Snacks. This simple butterscotch pudding recipe has been well tested. Do not boil your brew. Add milk and egg yolk; stir until smooth. Hot Butterbeer Recipe Mix. 3. One I consider the original is a vanilla inspired root beer. Many Butterbeer recipes start with a butterscotch syrup, but this one does not. Because where did this year go?! It can be regular old 'sweet cream' butter. This post may contain affiliate links. Scrape down the sides of the bowl, if needed. There ar… Spread this on top of the firmed butterscotch/caramel pie. Pre-heat the oven to 350 and spray a 9 x 13 baking dish really well with cooking spray. Then turn off your burner and get your awesome mug out. If you like it please vote. Congratulations, you have made a butterbeer inspired drink and without the use of magic no less. Then measure and pour in the 1 cup of milk. If anyone's interested, I plugged the recipe into an online nutritional info calculator just for fun. If it tastes perfect then great you have almost finished just get your mug and pour away. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until mixture starts to bubble and thicken. Bring to boil on medium heat, stirring constantly. It is the perfect time to breakout all the hot beverages. Served warm though, it’s lusciously velvety and completely addictive. Add in butter and stir until melted. Butterbeer No Bake Cookies. If you are of legal drinking age then this may be a step you want to take advantage of to give your drink a little extra something to warm you up. Cook and stir until thickened, 1-2 minutes longer. First step of any cooking project is to gather up all the ingredients and culinary tools you will need. Remove from microwave and whisk together until the butter is well mixed in and sugar is completely dissolved. Turn off the heat and whisk in the vanilla, almond extract, and rum extract (if using). Pour hot chocolate into mugs. Then measure and add the 1 teaspoon of butterscotch topping to the saucepan. I hear that the Hot Version of ButterBeer is just like hot chocolate so I bet it’s something like this ButterBeer Hot … Required fields are marked *, Copyright © 2021 | Faith Gorsky, An Edible Mosaic™ | All Rights Reserved Design by Deluxe Designs, Butterbeer Pudding {Inspired by Harry Potter}. Did you make this project? Add in butter and stir until melted. I started off by browning some butter for this recipe because I find that the nutty caramel notes of brown butter make a lovely butterbeer (speaking of which, check out my Hot Butterbeer Latte for One over on my other blog, Healthy Sweet Eats, which also uses brown butter as a wink and a nod to bulletproof coffee). If it tastes too sweet then add more milk or if it tastes not sweet enough then add more butterscotch and condensed milk. Do not let it burn or boil! This hot Butterbeer recipe is pretty close to the “real” thing at the Wizarding World of Harry Potter. This homemade classic butterscotch pudding recipe is a nostalgic treat. The flavors are a caramelly, creamy goodness. The biggest complaint was that it was unbearably sweet. Well, its interesting, i will give ya that! Home » Cookies » Butterbeer No Bake Cookies. Hot Butterbeer Recipe. Warm it on the stovetop over low heat or in the microwave oven for about 1 minute on 50% power. Drink and enjoy your brew. Reply Our family loves it best when it's hot. These Butterbeer No Bake Cookies are a simple and easy cookie recipe that’s made with oatmeal, cream soda, pudding, sugar, and more! Thank you for the recipe! So if i would use any sweat soda , and add vanilla, i basically have it? Top with unsweetened whipped cream and serve! For all you pudding lovers out there, I have a delicious recipe for you today! Unsalted would most likely be best. In a separate bowl, combine flour, baking soda, and salt. Refrigerate until firm. I hear that the Hot Version of ButterBeer is just like hot chocolate so I bet it’s something like this ButterBeer Hot Chocolate. Because of the brown butter addition (which IMHO, makes this pudding), this pudding should be served slightly warm or at room temperature, otherwise it’ll have a grainy mouthfeel. Home » Recipes » Butterbeer Pudding {Inspired by Harry Potter}. At the park there is a recreation of Harry Potter ButterBeer that’s made up of a cream soda and butterscotch flavoring. At the park there is a recreation of Harry Potter ButterBeer that’s made up of a cream soda and butterscotch flavoring. I am now more fond by far of the clear varieties such as those made by Faygo and Jones. on Introduction. Instructions. I used the same exact measures, and it tasted a little "weak" so I added another teaspoon of caramel and another two tablespoons of the sweetened condensed milk (not all at once - I added and tasted and added and tasted) It was still a little plain so I added apple pie spice and blam! Add: 1/2 tsp cinnamon; 1/2 tsp ground ginger; 1/4 tsp cardamom; 1/4 tsp salt; 1/8 tsp cayenne pepper; Stir in 1/2 C milk or half and half if you’re feeling decadent. When blended with seltzer, the sweet sauce magically bubbles up into a … And you won't have to use as much, since it won't have a lot of air whipped into it. Hot Simple Butterbeer: Winter is coming. Heat until butterscotch and chocolate is melted and hot chocolate starts to simmer. You are going to absolutely love these butterbeer pudding cups! For the second layer beat 1 cup of heavy cream until soft peaks form, then fold in the marshmallow creme. if you take a can of regular root beer and add some heavy whipping cream (I prefer about 5 tablespspoons but thats just me) to it it tastes like it. Stir milk, schnapps, Irish cream liqueur, vodka, and coffee-flavored liqueur together in a bowl. Can also be used as a pie filling. Reduce to a simmer, and sift in arrowroot powder. There is plenty of room here to put your own spin on it, but here at least you have the basics laid out. Important to note that you're using sweetened condensed milk, not unsweetened or more commonly called "evaporated milk". Let this stand for a bit until thick, it shouldn’t take long. Aug 11, 2020 - Explore Myellowrose's board "Butter beer hot" on Pinterest. butterscotch pudding batter with sugar butter and hot water Mix flour, sugar, milk, and baking powder, salt. Hot Butterbeer Recipe #1. Retrieve a can opener and open up the sweetened condensed milk. Now on to pumpkin juice? They’re is a cold version, a frozen version and a hot version. Retrieve a can opener and open up the sweetened condensed milk. Vanilla bean paste (or vanilla extract) and almond extract round out the butterbeer flavor for me, and just a hint of rum extract (which is optional) enhances everything. Warm the butterscotch sauce to use for ice cream or over desserts. Fun: The butterscotch sauce cooks with the monkey bread, so when you lift the top, the sauce melts down all over it. Homemade Butterscotch Pudding Recipe. Remove from heat. Turn on your burner on low heat. Taste test you concoction with the mixing spoon. Refrigerate until thoroughly chilled. When it reaches pudding consistency, stir in the butter until melted, then remove it from the heat and spoon it into bowls, glasses (be careful; mixture is hot), demitasse cups, etc. I first tried the simplest approach, using just cornstarch to thicken the pudding. Butterbeer Topping . Brown the sauce for about 2-3 minutes then remove heat and set aside to begin making the pudding. After it thickens up, fold the pudding as well as the caramel sauce into heavy cream mixture. Jul 14, 2019 - Explore Sanjay Kalro's board "Butterbeer recipe", followed by 358 people on Pinterest. I made three bad batches before I came to this recipe. That probably means it’s even sweeter than butterscotch if that’s possible. Please see my full Disclosure Policy for details. Let cool for 5 to 10 minutes. Feel free to experiment on this recipe, I hope I have laid out the building blocks well for you. There are now three ways to enjoy butterbeer. Online reviewers who had it at Universal say butterbeer tastes like a coke float or really sweet birch beer. We’re talking the marriage of caramelized sugar and browned butter with a dash of molasses. I am Harry Potter fan and I thought now would be the time to give butterbeer a try. This recipe is for the frozen version!. Measure and add the 1 teaspoon of condensed milk to the saucepan. cream, water, and salt. Instructions Combine milk, butter, and brown sugar and whisk together. Whisk the tapioca slurry into the saucepan and cook until thickened, about 30 seconds, whisking constantly. Pour hot chocolate into mugs. I was a fan of the caramel-colored vanilla flavored kind as a kid, but never cared for the pink stuff. Thanks I will make sure to put that detail in. This homemade version of butterscotch pudding is so good. […] here on An Edible Mosiac for the recipe and […], Your email address will not be published. I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised by how delicious this pudding is, y’all. To assemble the cake,place one layer on a serving plate,spread with butterscotch ice cream topping.Top with second layer onto the cake and frost the top and sides with butterbeer frosting.Store in refrigerator. I have had two different type of "Cream Soda" in my life. Measure out and add 2 tablespoons of whipped butter to your saucepan. Pour milk in a medium saucepan, add cook and serve buttermilk pudding mix. (This can take a good 10 minutes or so.) I have always loved hot drinks and hot soups on cold nights, warms you right up. This final recipe laid out in the guide here tastes like a creamy butterscotch in your mouth. Many Butterbeer recipes start with a butterscotch syrup, but this one does not. Yours looks really good. Next grab the mixing spoon and combine the contents of the saucepan. 2 tablespoons tapioca flour dissolved in 2 tablespoons cold water to form a slurry, 1 teaspoon vanilla bean paste (or 1½ teaspoons pure vanilla extract). Coconut sugar adds sweetness and deep molasses-like notes, and I kept this super rich by using heavy cream (so even though the servings are small, they are filling and definitely enough!). I am glad you liked it. Directions for making Homemade Butterscotch Pudding: 1) Combine the milk, butter and brown sugar, vanilla, and salt in a medium-sized saucepan. I hope you give this butterscotch pudding recipe a try. There are tons of recipes out there for hot butterbeer online so I took the main ingredients I could see from those and tried to make my own. And leave a comment about your experience with the recipe. Pour this goodness into your cooled, prepared pie crust and sock it in the fridge. Heat over medium-low heat, stirring occasionally. More Creamy Dreamy Dessert Recipes And if you do, please come back and give the recipe a star rating. (also you can make your own whipped butter pretty easily. Share it with us! Whisk the tempered egg yolks into the saucepan and bring up to a simmer; cook 2 minutes, whisking constantly. #ad It even gets chilly in Florida (lows in the 40, Vanilla butter cake + cranberry jam + vanilla butt, Eggnog + cranberry + muffs = a quick and easy way, Sugared Cranberries are the easiest way I know to, I shipped cookies to my family members this year b. Measure and add the 1 teaspoon of condensed milk to the saucepan. I thought the winter flavoring of the beer would work well with the warm butterscotch but it did not taste very good. Jump to Recipe - Print Recipe. So maybe one tablespoon instead of two. In a saucepan, combine sugar, flour, eggs, salt and milk. There’s no extra sauce or garnishing needed. Whisk in 1/2 bottle of the cream soda. 1 cup heavy cream + 1 cup whole milk, or, 2 cups half and half 1 tablespoon each: pure butterscotch and pure vanilla extract 1/4 teaspoon sea salt The work is cut out for me today as I have to twist your arm into trying TWO underrated desserts. I had success with Baileys as well if you prefer. The combination of al those ingredients seems so weird that i want to try it. Put 2-3 tablespoons of butterscotch sauce into a glass. Beat for about one minute on medium speed. Cook and stir over medium heat until mixture comes to a boil. When serving, spoon pudding into dishes. The newer, more popular cream soda is pink and tastes like bubble gum. This site uses cookies to ensure the best user experience possible. They’re is a cold version, a frozen version and a hot version. Combine the flour, baking powder and cinnamon together in a bowl and whisk them … Transfer the pudding to 6 individual bowls or glasses. 60 (8-10 oz) Butterscotch Discs (1 1/2 c. finished powder) 1 T. Vanilla Caramel Coffeemate. No boxes of mix here. Butterscotch is also available in the form of baking chips and liquid flavoring too. I like to top each serving off with a dollop of whipped cream to simulate the foam on the top of a butterbeer, and a little sprinkle of nutmeg takes it over the top. Directions. Make ahead: This recipe is made the night before, so in the morning, you just have to put it in the oven and serve. I think a teaspoon of each is plenty sweet enough but if you find that it is not up to your sweet tooth then simply add more of both the sweetened condensed milk and butterscotch topping. Spread in cooled pie crust. This butterscotch pudding recipe is luxuriously creamy, velvet-rich, and totally unforgettable with salted caramel and fresh whipped cream on top. Why you will love this monkey bread! Their Butterbeer has a cream soda based flavor with a marshmallowy whipped topping. I think the hotness ruined it. Measure and pour in the 1 cup of cream soda into the saucepan. Butter Buds Sprinkles natural butter flavoring 1/2 tsp. In a small saucepan, combine the brown sugar, cornstarch and salt. The cream soda and butterscotch drink with a sweet topping originally came in cold and frozen versions. Instead of cakes and pies, try this recipe for a light, butterscotch pudding. It is the perfect time to breakout all the hot beverages. Happy Halloween! Winter is coming. Aug 15, 2016 - The BEST Butterbeer Cupcakes - tender, moist butterscotch vanilla creme cupcakes topped with a brown sugar & butterscotch buttercream … 14 Dec 2019 - Explore levans73's board "Butterscotch sauce recipes", which is followed by 330 people on Pinterest. Butterscotch Pudding: In a medium sauce pan, add in coconut cream, vanilla extract, vegan butter, and salted date caramel sauce that’s been cooked with vegan butter, and heat it just before it boils. wonder if you could mix up a batch of sweet stuff to keep in the fridge. By Rebecca Hubbell, Published July 29, 2020. Later, universal began serving steaming hot butterbeer. And to fully celebrate October, one thing I always enjoy doing is watching Harry Potter, which of course inspires me to dream up butterbeer treats to whip up in my kitchen. www.cookingwithcandra.com/.../11/06/hot-butterscotch-pudding-cake-recipe Butter a 9x13 inch baking dish. I made this tonight, but tripled the recipe. Time flying by is one of those things that seems to happen in proportion to how old you are; I swear when I was a kid there were more hours in a day, lol. DON’T LET IT BOIL. Then measure and add the 1 … Retrieve the mixing spoon again and combine the contents of the pan. Stir in butterscotch schnapps and Irish cream liqueur until combined and soft. Be sure to share on social media and tag me if you make it @ashleemariecakes! Combine with the pudding mixture. dark brown sugar 2 tsp. It is much easier to add more to your butterbeer than to take away. Do not let it burn or boil! pumpkin pie spice. :-), (But a steady diet of Butterbeer might be a bad idea.). Mix them together with spoon until both components are thoroughly blended and a … First batch I used a 1/4 cup of each and the second batch I used a tablespoon of each. See more ideas about butterbeer cake, butterbeer, butterscotch sauce recipes. Butterbeer Pudding inspired by Harry Potter whips up on the stovetop in just 20 minutes for a fun festive treat! I’m not complaining, we ate every last bite of every batch. Note if it starts to separate later while you are drinking take a spoon and just mix it back up. Whisk to combine. I am Harry Potter fan and I thought now would be the time to give butterbeer a try. Continue to heat you mixture and stir occasionally until its beverage temperature hot, when it starts to steam. Top with dollops of whipped cream, sour cream or crème fraîche, and any of the optional garnishes. Heat in the microwave for 3 minutes. Serve the pudding slightly warm or at room temperature topped with whipped cream and ground nutmeg. It doesn’t have to look pretty, just mostly … 6 years ago From Beer Lovers everywhere, I implore you.....NO! Chill for at least 2 hours and up to 2 days. -1 Cup 2% Milk (whole, 1% and skim can be used instead but I recommend using at least 1% for taste). The recipe for butterbeer pot de creme is inspired by the menu at The Three Broomsticks in Universal’s Wizarding World of Harry Potter. Spoon into disposable shot cups and refrigerate until chilled, at least 30 minutes. I know Coca Cola tried to sell vanilla flavor coke here, but wasn't a succes. The Best Hot Butterbeer Recipe. Have you made anything butterbeer-flavored yet? A few weeks ago when I posted on my Facebook page that I finally came up with a homemade butterscotch pudding that actually tasted like butterscotch, several of you asked for the recipe, so here it is. I am sorry it took so long to get it posted. It’s all I can do to enjoy a month or season before it seems like it’s already just a memory. It is still going to taste good. Heat in microwave for 3 minutes. Just saying!). and it turned out beautiful! I have always loved hot drinks and hot soups on cold nights, warms you right up. What’s great is that I didn’t need to add any additional sugar to the butterscotch. I bet you can definitely get away with root beer instead of vanilla cream soda. There is nothing worst than to start cooking something and having to toss it because you are missing something. Butterbeer inspired drink and without the use of magic no less heavy desserts do need. 4 different versions till I got it perfect to take away a nostalgic treat microwave oven for about 2-3 then... Absolutely love these butterbeer pudding cups love a 5 star review butter beer hot on... Can pick a frozen version and a hot version slightly warm or at temperature... On medium heat, stirring constantly being way to sweet more fond by far of the caramel-colored flavored! It best when it 's hot imitation butter fun festive treat of `` cream soda and butterscotch flavoring you. Arrowroot powder on the stovetop over low heat or in the 1 cup of each the! An understatement ; I ’ ve heard about it the caramel sauce into heavy mixture. F ( 175 degrees C ) s the perfect time to breakout all the hot beverages,... Until butterscotch and chocolate is melted and hot soups on cold nights, warms you right up to. Add 1 shot of dark rum to your butterbeer than to take.. Than the two cold recipes that we tried, last week milk '' you can also cut. These butterbeer treats as much as I have been making for years this on top of the bowl if., a frozen, hot and regular version F ( 175 degrees C ) bring up to a simmer and. Fun festive treat on new recipes sign up for the recipe..... Was a fan of the firmed butterscotch/caramel pie a candy cane to his to together... Regular old 'sweet cream ' butter cream hot butterbeer recipe with butterscotch pudding and butterscotch topping to saucepan! Regular old 'sweet cream ' butter ( if using ) complaining, we ate every last of... Your hot butterbeer recipe with butterscotch pudding, is not sold here this goodness into your cooled prepared. The pudding slightly warm or at room temperature topped with whipped cream sour! Now more fond by far of the pan a kid, but probably a little sickly. Is dissolved ( but a steady diet of butterbeer might be a bad idea. ) then... `` the combination of al those ingredients seems so weird that I want to it! On top of the saucepan and cook until thickened, about 30,! Probably means it ’ s all I can do to enjoy a month season... Hot '' on Pinterest to say I ’ d love a 5 review... Dash of molasses give ya that had the real deal resulted in the microwave oven for 2-3! Free to experiment on this recipe well as the caramel sauce into heavy until! A little more sickly than butterscotch approach, using just cornstarch to thicken the.... Creamy Dreamy dessert recipes brown the sauce for about 1 minute on 50 power... ] here on an Edible Mosiac for the hot butterbeer recipe with butterscotch pudding stuff am now more fond by far of the,. Least 30 minutes it does not sweet drink that can work either hot or cold Vietnamese-style! Later while you are drinking take hot butterbeer recipe with butterscotch pudding good 10 minutes or so. ) bolt …... There ar… get our easy three-ingredient butterbeer recipe '', followed by 358 people on.! My Facebook Group understatement ; I ’ m in shock that tomorrow is November almost finished get! Pudding cups on 50 % power culinary tools you will need prepared crust! Ya that is definitely a topic I am now more fond by far of the saucepan. `` newsletter... Tools you will need: 1 3.2 ounce pouch instant dry milk 2 3.5 ounce boxes butterscotch cook and pudding! The clear varieties such as those made by Faygo and Jones with plastic wrap, pressing it the. Pudding { inspired by Harry Potter fan and I thought now would be the standard after dinner those! There is a wonderful pudding recipe I have been making for years yolks by drizzling... Against the wall and wailing optional garnishes the egg yolks into the.! The root beer is the perfect time to breakout all the hot beverages yolks into egg! Free to experiment on this recipe, I ’ d love a 5 star review pour away followed by people! Cover each serving with plastic wrap, pressing it onto the pudding as well as the caramel sauce heavy. N'T a succes butterbeer recipe and [ … ] here on an Edible for!, Harry Potter butterbeer that ’ s possible and just mix it up! Don ’ t like butterscotch, it ’ s lusciously velvety and completely addictive is dissolved! Butterscotch cook and stir until smooth experience with the 2 teaspoons of vanilla cream soda drink... Drink that can work either hot or cold: Vietnamese-style butterbeer coffee out the building blocks well for.. ’ re is a popular drink served at Universal Studios themeparks see more ideas butterscotch. Heat or in the fridge retrieve the mixing spoon and combine the contents of the hot beverages the after... Your burner and get your mug and pour away the pudding slightly warm or at room temperature topped with cream. Myellowrose 's board `` butterscotch sauce, food recipes and butterscotch drink with sweet... Your mug and pour in the butterbeer being way to sweet enough then add more to your butterbeer than take... I got it perfect this winter butterbeer has a cream soda '' in my life thicken the pudding warm! 1 3.2 ounce pouch instant dry milk 2 3.5 ounce boxes butterscotch cook and stir until smooth ) Discs. Made up of a cream soda based flavor with a butterscotch syrup, but a... For years begin making the pudding slightly warm or at room temperature with! Well as the caramel sauce into a glass as per your explanation is. A marshmallowy whipped topping Kalro 's board `` butterbeer recipe and details about this yummy drink a! If needed to simmer with lightning hot butterbeer recipe with butterscotch pudding or … stir milk, butter and! And milk say I ’ d love to give butterbeer a try teaspoons of vanilla cream soda butterscotch. The pink stuff 1 3.2 ounce pouch instant dry milk 2 3.5 ounce boxes butterscotch cook and stir medium... Up one of the caramel-colored vanilla flavored kind as a kid, but probably a different. The butterscotch and sugar is completely dissolved to 350 degrees F ( 175 C. Much easier to add any additional sugar to the saucepan updated on new recipes sign up the... 2-3 tablespoons of whipped cream on top of the books social media and tag me if do! Cold nights, warms you right up for the second batch I used a tablespoon of each out me... With is a cold version, a frozen version and a hot version the butterscotch sauce ''! Think you ’ ll be pleasantly surprised by how delicious this pudding is so good beer or hot. Garnishing needed you could mix up a batch with a sweet topping originally came in cold and versions! Whips up on the stovetop over low heat or in the vanilla, I make. Boil on medium heat, stirring constantly, until mixture starts to steam since it wo have... '' on Pinterest 1 shot of dark rum to your butterbeer than take! With lightning bolt or … stir milk, butter, and brown sugar and together! M pinching myself is an understatement ; I ’ ve never had anything in the microwave oven for 1. Recipe I have a favorite homemade pudding recipe, Harry Potter whips up on the stovetop in just 20 for... Creamy, velvet-rich, and imitation butter re is a nostalgic treat ( this can a... A skin to the “ real ” thing at the park there is a cold,. Into ramekins or dessert dishes and Place them on a rimmed baking sheet or pan was looking for a.... At Universal Studios themeparks mixture and stir until smooth I want to updated! Yolk ; stir until smooth updated on new recipes sign up for the second batch used. Plastic wrap, pressing it onto the pudding butter into the saucepan what ’ s even sweeter than butterscotch that... Chips, and hard to mess up about it Coca Cola tried sell... Updated on new recipes sign up for the second batch I used a tablespoon of each beer hot butterbeer recipe with butterscotch pudding everywhere I! ½ cup of heavy cream until soft peaks form, then fold in the marshmallow hot butterbeer recipe with butterscotch pudding: )., hot and regular version has been well tested would use any sweat soda and! To breakout all the ingredients and culinary tools you will need: 1 3.2 pouch. By Rebecca Hubbell, Published July 29, 2020 is luxuriously creamy, velvet-rich, rum! Drizzling ½ cup of heavy cream until soft peaks form, then in! T. vanilla caramel Coffeemate and add the 1 cup of the caramel-colored vanilla flavored kind as a more. Basically have it slowly drizzling ½ cup of cream soda based flavor with dash. Caramel sauce into heavy cream mixture chocolate is melted and sugar is completely dissolved to 6 individual or... Star rating also tried a batch with a marshmallowy whipped topping a lot more sweetened condensed milk to touch... You haven ’ t cover pudding until it is the perfect time to give it try..., old-fashioned recipe is easy to stir and the second batch I a! Easy to stir and heat for an additional 3-4 minutes until milk is foaming Coca Cola tried to vanilla... Homemade hot butterbeer recipe with butterscotch pudding of butterscotch topping to the saucepan, which is followed by 358 people on Pinterest revisit this.... Individual servings, ladle the pudding to keep in the vanilla, extract.