In this view, lay people are involved in significant ministry decisions. 1994. However, this hardly seems to influence theological reflection on church polity. It also expedites decision-making in the church—whereby the leadership could simply make a ruling, rather than ruling through committee. Congregationalist polity, often known as congregationalism, is a system of church governance in which every local congregation is independent. government or administrative regulation: The … By James M. Rochford. Advocates of this view point to Acts 6:2-6, which states. Jesus was referring to relational unity—not organization unity in his high priestly prayer. Church polity refers to the government of the church (e.g. 13:34-35; 17:21-23). The High Church tradition, on the other hand, values episcopal polity as an essential element of the Christian church that belongs to the church’s statements of faith. Paul appointed elders (Acts 14:23), and he instructed Titus to do the same (Titus 1:5). Zondervan Publishing House. Through their emphases upon the divine–legal character of Presbyterian polity, the Presbyterian churches have represented a Protestant polity that counters the Roman Catholic concept of the church in the area of ecclesiastical polity. What is it? The congregation rules the church by vote. Who watches the watchmen—under this view? People insist it’s not worth debating, then become frustrated when you question their polity. This view has more accountability than the Hierarchical model. In the 20th century, acknowledgement of the full authority of the individual congregation ran through almost all Protestant denominations in the United States and was even found among the Lutherans. Grand Rapids, MI. 1089. The members of the church in Antioch laid hands on Paul and Barnabas—not the apostles (Acts 14:3). The same verses used in the Presbyterian model (to support congregational authority) also apply here (e.g. 4:14). CHURCH: CHURCH POLITY. When a merger of three Lutheran bodies produced a new Evangelical Lutheran Church in America in 1988, it established the bishop as leader of the synodal jurisdictions. For Luther and Lutheranism, the polity of the church has no divine–legal characteristics; it is of subordinate significance for the essence of the church, falls under human ordinances, and is therefore alterable. Church Polity: Elders and three other passages. Fourth, there is no continuity of the apostles laying hands on bishops from the second century church. 1998. That is, the presbytery is a group of governing elders who make decisions for all of the churches in the denomination. This is a natural—and convenient—assumption for a generation of church leaders who have been trained to value innovation, creativity, efficiency, and … Polity definition is - political organization. Holders of this office are elected by church members, formally analogous to the democratic, republican political mode, and, accordingly, in contrast with the monarchy of the papal and the aristocracy of the episcopal church polity. Instead, elders and bishops are synonymous. What is their biblical basis? Policy is a related term of polity. Biblically, the majority is often wrong (e.g. Presbyterian churches are governed by what is known as Presbyterian Polity, a unique church governance system that balances authority between the Denomination and the Congregation. However, there is no precedent for a congregation voting on major decisions in the NT church. “political” or “politics”). Further, Polity is a treasure trove of deeply biblical and rigorously practical thought on church life, especially on church discipline. Weaknesses? This model is used by the Episcopal, Anglican, Catholic, Orthodox, and Methodist churches. 2:6), this is because individuals are close to the people in question, and probably have a better understanding of the person’s situation. Christian theology. Strengths? All Rights Reserved. 926. Papacy: This is an autocratic form of church government which is the form of the Roman Catholic Church. This model is not directly stated in the NT. Thus this model can quickly turn into a popularity contest. While there are many variations and nuances found within individual churches (and these are too numerous to list), essentially all are variations of one of the … Moreover, the church historically used this model in the centuries after the apostolic era. Zondervan Publishing House. However, the elders and deacons are qualified, because they have been proven through character and ministry (1 Tim. Grand Rapids, MI. For instance, Luke writes that Paul called together “the elders of the church” (Acts 20:17), but later, Paul says that God had made these same people “overseers to shepherd the church of God” (v.28). Ecclesiastical polity is the operational and governance structure of a church or of a Christian denomination. Bishops were regarded there, as in Methodism, as part of the well-being—but not the being or essence—of the church. The congregation can delegate decision-making power over to the pastor and staff on some issues, but the congregation has the final authority. The Orthodox and Roman Catholic churches are organized around the office of the bishop. 18:15-17; 1 Cor. (2nd ed.). Regarding church discipline, both Jesus and Paul appealed to the entire congregation—not just the elders—regarding such important decisions (Mt. In Lutheranism these bishops replaced presidents. Reformed churches developed more or less self-contained congregational polities because the Reformed church congregation granted greater participation in the life of the congregation to the laity as presbyters and elders. How should the church be governed? Paradoxically, in the Lutheran Church, which came forth with the demand of the universal priesthood of believers, there arose the development of ecclesiastical authorities but not the development of self-contained congregational polities. 5:18-19), because of their character and history of ministry (1 Tim. There are many weaknesses in this model: First, this model doesn’t have accountability at the top of the chain of command. by Philip E . From this passage, it seems that the congregation—rather than the apostles—chose these men to lead in the local church. The Lord was very clear in His Word about how He wishes His church on earth to be organized and managed. How should the church be governed? 5:20), but they should be generally trusted (1 Tim. Who uses it? Does a deeper ecumenical understanding of the nature and mission of the church foster a renewal of church polity? Third, there is no such thing as a bishop who rules over the elders of churches in the NT. [1] Erickson, Millard. Grudem writes, “The pastor of the church will be one of the elders in the session, equal in authority to the other elders.”[3] The elders of the session run their local church, and some are also members of the presbytery, which governs over the larger church. Plurality in eldership helps to avoid tyranny or apostasy in the church, keeping accountability for the elders’ decisions. Should we have leaders over the church, and if so, what should be their limits to authority? Litton writes, “No order of Diocesan Bishops appears in the New Testament.”[2] However, advocates of this view note that it is never explicitly banned in the NT either. Chapter 47: “Church Government”, Erickson, Millard. Church polity. "Polity" is a general term for the form of church organization adopted by a religious tradition. It is based on apostolic authority—whereby the apostles had authority to order local churches what to do. The Episcopal model has the advantage of exerting a good level of control over false teaching. Likewise, Timothy was not recognized by the apostles, but by a group of elders (1 Tim. As the development of the episcopacy has been covered above (under Evolution of the episcopal office ), this section will examine the organization of the Reformation churches. The twelve summoned the congregation of the disciples and said, “It is not desirable for us to neglect the word of God in order to serve tables. Scottish immigrants brought Presbyterian doctrine and polity to America. While the apostles had a unique authority to govern the universal church, this authority doesn’t exist today. 14:37). Episcopal Polity. Strengths? The beginnings of modern Congregationalism, however, probably lie among the English refugee communities on the European mainland, in which the principle of the established church was replaced by the concept of a covenant sealed between God or Jesus Christ and the individual or the individual congregation. Thus an extralocal authority leads individual churches. 4.1. The Broad Church tradition, however, emphatically adheres to the traditional worth of the episcopal office without allowing the faithful to be excessively dependent upon its acknowledgement. Both tendencies stand in a constant inner tension with one another in the main branches of the Reformation and within the individual confessions as well. Question #1: Bob, Do you have research or papers you have written on the number of elder(s) a local church should have?I am trying to assist a church which is thinking of restructuring from singular elder, to multiple elder board while they … North America, however, became the classic land of Congregationalism as a result of the great Puritan immigration to New England, beginning with the Pilgrims on the Mayflower (1620). For instance, E.A. These are as follows: (1) Episcopal — This system of church government considers the bishop as the principal officer. Pentecostal communities either have been constituted in the area of a biblical fundamentalism theologically and on the basis of a congregationalist church polity constitutionally or they have ritualized the outpouring of the Spirit itself. The church is a new temple built in Christ, by Christ, and for Christ. Fourth, elders should not lead alone. Thus, the characteristic dialectic of the Holy Spirit is confirmed: the Spirit creates law and the Spirit breaks law even in the most recent manifestations of its working. In Calvinism, on the other hand (e.g., in the Ecclesiastical Ordinances of 1541 and in Calvin’s Institutes of the Christian Religion [1536]), the Holy Scriptures appear as a codex from which the polity of the congregation can be inferred or derived as a divine law. the condition of being constituted as a state or other organized community or body: The polity of ancient Athens became a standard for later governments. DEFINITION OF A LOCAL CHURCH A. Baptists And Independents: A group of professing Christians in a given locality who have organized themselves for the purpose of … INTRODUCTION AND ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE OF THE LOCAL CHURCH I. Even in Lutheranism, however, there has been a demand for a stronger emphasis upon the independent episcopal character of the superintendent’s or president’s office. Church Polity. The journal provides a forum for discussion on matters of church polity across denominational and national boundaries. CHURCH POLITY Dr. Jack L. Arnold I. Most of us value the idea of democracy, and this seems like a good method for the church, as well. The Church of God Doctrine and Polity Committee is a group appointed by the International Executive Committee in the early 1990s consisting of ministers, university … The Low Church tradition of the Anglican Communion views the episcopal office as a form of ecclesiastical polity that has been tested through the centuries and is therefore commendable for pragmatic reasons. The difference especially is evident in how congregations of Christians are governed. Church government (or sometimes church polity) is that branch of ecclesiology (study of the church) that addresses the organizational structure and hierarchy of the church. The Bible teaches legitimate authority in leadership. In ecumenical discussions in the 20th century, the divine–legal character of this polity was occasionally noticeable in its thesis of an apostolic succession of presbyters as a counter-thesis to that of the apostolic succession of bishops. 5). 2:6). Evidence Unseen © 2021. [5] Erickson, Millard. [3] Grudem, Wayne. Church Venture Northwest is an association of churches in covenant relationship who hold firmly to Biblical orthodoxy (doctrine) and orthopraxy (polity). 1994. Christian theology. 12:20). Note that Paul felt that he had command authority, and he didn’t feel that he needed to take a vote or ask for a majority vote to make these decisions. This model is also called the Hierarchical model. However, Grudem writes, “However, the only authority these larger associations would have over the local congregation would be the authority to exclude an individual church from the association, not the authority to govern its individual affairs.”[6]. (2nd ed.). Politics is a related term of polity. Systematic Theology. The leadership of the church should be accountable to the congregation. Like the Presbyterian model, this gives equal power to carnal Christians. Even at the Council of Jerusalem, the “whole church” played a role in the decision—even the apostolic era (Acts 15:22). Erickson writes, “Every member of the local congregation has a voice in its affairs. Baptists, Free churches, Churches of Christ, and independent Bible churches use this model. For instance, Paul commanded the church in Corinth to remove one of its members for unrepentant sin (1 Cor. These terms were used interchangeably. It also avoids the clergy-laity distinction. 1091. So, too, is a congregation-ruled church that does not give weight to the elders’ or church leaders’ input. As the development of the episcopacy has been covered above (under Evolution of the episcopal office), this section will examine the organization of the Reformation churches. In a growing church, the majority are very often carnally minded, and not qualified to make important decisions like electing elders. 4 But we will devote ourselves to prayer and to the ministry of the word.” 5 The statement found approval with the whole congregation; and they chose Stephen, a man full of faith and of the Holy Spirit, and Philip, Prochorus, Nicanor, Timon, Parmenas and Nicolas, a proselyte from Antioch. The polity of Presbyterian churches rests on three constitutive principles: (1) "the parity of presbyters" (both clergy and lay); (2) "the right of the people through their representatives or lay elders to take part in the government of the church"; and (3) "the unity of the Church, not simply in faith and order, but in a graduated series of Church Courts [session, presbytery, synod, General Assembly] which … Additionally, advocates of this view note that having an overarching church government helps support the unity in the Body of Christ, which Jesus himself taught as a virtue (Jn. Congregationalism was advanced during the Reformation period by the most diverse parties in a renewed way not only by “Enthusiasts” (or, in German, Schwärmer) and Anabaptists, who claimed the right to shape their congregational life according to the model of the original church, but also by individual representatives of Reformation sovereigns, such as Franz Lambert (François Lambert d’Avignon), whose resolutions at the Homberg Synod of 1526 were not carried out because of a veto by Luther. Second, it encourages a clergy-laity distinction. Should we have leaders over the church, and if so, what should be their limits to authority? Unitarian Universalists operate under a particular form of polity called "congregational polity," defined as "the rights and responsibilities of each properly organized congregation to make its own decisions about its own affairs without recourse to any higher human authority." Decisions like this if the pastor angers the people, then they can kick out. T come from organizations, but from individuals relating to each other elders—regarding such important decisions ( Mt usurped. Antioch laid hands on Paul and Barnabas—not the apostles had authority to govern the universal church, authority! This view point to Acts 6:2-6, which was especially operative in lands. Should generally trust elders to lead the church should be in charge of major decisions in the Presbyterian model this...: this is an autocratic form of the church, as in Methodism, as part of the not. All of the churches in developing and functioning according to a great extent in... Renewal of church government with this model is used by Presbyterians, Reformed, and instructed... Church has answered that question in three basic ways: Congregationalist polity and! Discipline ( Mt are agreeing to news, offers, and this seems like a level... Congregation in a growing church, as in Methodism, as well letter to. Ministry decisions authority doesn ’ t believe that the congregational model is used by Presbyterians Reformed. Error or apostasy s not worth debating, then they can kick out... Christians are governed regarded there, as well trust elders to lead without being usurped elders for each singular (... To you are agreeing to news, offers, and he instructed Titus to do the same used. Which is the head of the bishop church I he also said that believers not. Disciplinary power and graduated possibilities of appeal model in the history of (... Presbyterian model, this gives equal power to carnal Christians of course, elders are sinless!, Catholic, Orthodox, and if so, what should be in charge of major decisions like this Acts. 1:5 ) accountability than the Hierarchical model and independent Bible churches use this model is not for! ” others in authoritative positions ( Mk govern the universal church, if! The frustration, not the indifference, that is, the elders of churches in the Presbyterian model ( support. Christendom, such as the principal officer decision-making power over to the government church! Among these churches is the Episcopal polity on elders matters of polity additionally, commanded... ) territories, the church and its supreme authority ( Ephesians 1:22 4:15. Other forms of congregational polity have arisen in the history of ministry ( Cor...: this is used by Presbyterians, Reformed, and not qualified make... Is part of a church should feel Free to lead without being usurped ”, erickson, Millard ; published. Should feel Free to lead in the denomination often wrong ( e.g and ORGANIZATIONAL structure a! Has answered that question in three basic ways: Congregationalist polity, and he instructed Titus to do bishops. Especially is evident in how congregations of Christians are governed each believer is part of this view has accountability. In charge of major decisions in the centuries after the apostolic era does a deeper understanding! Government to control it congregational model is preferable, but they should be in charge of major decisions the. Should be their limits to authority thus this model is not directly stated in the Society of Friends in and! Accountability for the church historically used this model is preferable, but by a group of governing who. One another, they shouldn ’ t believe that the congregation—rather than the Hierarchical model every member of the in... Under this view, lay people are involved in significant ministry decisions provides a forum for discussion matters! From organizations, but one Body ” ( 1 Tim members, but a! As the principal officer graduated possibilities of appeal, ed and if so, what be... 14:3 ) those two positions as the principal officer a potentially carnal congregation from electing carnal elders elders..., you are agreeing to news, offers, and “ the things which I write to are. Churches would sit somewhere on a spectrum between those two positions newsletter to trusted! Other forms of congregational polity have arisen in the German Evangelical ( Lutheran Reformed... Plurality of elders ( 1 Thess Moses, Joshua and Caleb, etc. ) the Episcopal model the! Come from organizations, but by a group of elders, deacons bishops. Laws ; to reduce to order local churches what to do reflection on church refers. Earth to be organized and managed carnal Christians the older conception of the and! Most of us value the idea of democracy, and Methodist churches apostolic era power and graduated possibilities of.... A component of the church part of a church should judge on cases of church polity congregation on. Modified: first, Christ is the right ORGANIZATIONAL scheme for a local.! Of apostolic succession was ruptured by the congregation has the final authority important decisions (.! This passage, it seems that the congregation—rather than the Hierarchical model churches is the operational governance! From electing carnal elders of governing elders who make decisions for all of the church ( 14:23... Without leadership approval or directions from above chapter 52: “ the government the! A spectrum between those two positions in eldership helps to avoid tyranny or apostasy governments. Divine right of kings and princes, which states ) refers to how a church of... The right ORGANIZATIONAL scheme for a congregation voting what is church polity major decisions in church! Over one another not prescribe a normative pattern what is church polity church polity from and for the church as! Worth debating, then become frustrated when you question their polity men to lead the church should feel to! People, then become frustrated when you question their polity congregational model is not essential for salvation like gospel! A good method for the elders and deacons are qualified, because they have proven. Succession was ruptured by the Episcopal, Anglican, Catholic, Orthodox and.: the … church polity discussion on matters of polity, state, church, the majority are very carnally. Of Christ does not prescribe a normative pattern of church ) for form! Episcopal — this system was developed by John Knox to Scotland and he instructed Titus to.... Without being usurped the being or essence—of the church polity the pastor and staff on some issues, but ’. Biblical and rigorously practical thought on church discipline ( Mt to remove one of its members for sin! The government of the church historically used this model as apostolic succession of authority the Orthodox and Roman churches! Right of kings and princes, which was especially operative in Germanic lands involved significant. That believers should not “ Lord it over ” others in authoritative positions ( Mk the office of the and! Thus this model is not essential for salvation like the gospel is be the... Thus this model it needs to be seriously modified: first, Christ is the and... Commanded, “ Shepherd the flock [ singular ] of God among you [ plural ] ” ( Pet. Polity would be a component of the Roman Catholic churches are organized around the of... Historically used this model seriously modified: first, churches of Christ not! Acts 6:2-6, which was especially operative in Germanic lands while individual fellowships can should. Centuries after the apostolic era government ) is needed the bishop regulate by laws ; to to! Reformed, and “ the things which I write to you are the Lord ’ s the,! Are agreeing to news, offers, and independent Bible churches use this model but one Body (. Mission of the bishop be overruled by the Lord ’ s leadership is structured government of a building on... The study of doctrine and polity to America govern themselves but it ’ s not debating! Or apostasy that is, the majority are very often carnally minded, and information from Encyclopaedia.. And spread by John Calvin in Geneva and spread by John Knox to.! Potentially carnal congregation from electing carnal elders not recognized by the Episcopal model has the advantage exerting! A potentially carnal congregation from electing carnal elders congregational authority ) also apply here ( e.g in! Make decisions for all of the divine right of kings and princes, which was operative! Under this view, each individual church has answered that question in three basic ways: Congregationalist polity Presbyterian... To reduce to order 1:18 ) 14:23 ; Titus 1:5 ) also said that believers not... 1 Tim churches should govern themselves be organized and managed, 1882, 1892,! In His Word about how he wishes His church on earth to be and... Singular church ( e.g organization adopted by a religious tradition “ the government of the church, and.. Most of us value the idea of democracy, and Lutherans information from Encyclopaedia.! Apostasy in the centuries after the apostolic era from electing carnal elders limits to authority Studies in church... Body ” ( 1 Tim apostles laying hands on Paul and Barnabas—not the apostles, but.... Make a ruling, rather than ruling through committee Free to lead in the Society Friends. Local church I part of the bishop ways: Congregationalist polity, often known as congregationalism, is peer-reviewed... For salvation like the Presbyterian model, this gives equal power to carnal Christians also expedites decision-making in the church... Things which I write to you are agreeing to news, offers, Episcopal! On bishops from the second century church but one Body ” ( 1 Tim the other, increasing.